In the shadow of the nuclear apocalypse that shaped the Fallout universe, Vault-Tec stands as a monument to both human ingenuity and moral ambiguity. Their vaults, meant to protect humanity from the ravages of atomic warfare, also served as clandestine laboratories for experiments that would challenge our notions of ethics, survival, and governance. Let's delve into some of these experiments, scrutinizing their intentions and outcomes, and explore the ethical horrors they present.
Listen to this article!
The History in Making
Tim Cain, one of the original creators of Fallout, introduced the concept of Vault-Tec experiments during the development of Fallout 2. Initially, the vaults in the first Fallout were more about survival and less about experiments. However, as the lore expanded, Cain decided to add depth to the Vault-Tec narrative.
The developers at Black Isle Studios (Interplay's division) wanted to explain why some vaults failed or why they had bizarre outcomes. The vaults were not just shelters but also a way to explore different societal experiments, each with its own twisted logic. This added layers to the game's world, providing both horror and humor, which became hallmarks of the series.
Years later, Cain elaborated on his original intention in interviews and on his YouTube channel, suggesting that some vault experiments were designed to gather data for interstellar travel or long-term space colonization. This added a layer of speculative science fiction to the already rich tapestry of Fallout's narrative.
While the initial idea was set in Fallout 2, subsequent games by Bethesda and Obsidian Entertainment expanded on this concept. Each game introduced new vaults with their own experiments, each more bizarre or sinister than the last, enhancing the lore and deepening the moral questions posed by these scenarios.
The Vaults: A Breeding Ground for Experiments
Each of Vault experiments showcases Vault-Tec's willingness to treat human life as expendable in the name of "science" or "survival", reflecting on themes of control, ethics, and the human capacity for both resilience and cruelty. Here's one particularly chilling vault experiment from each main Fallout game (and TV Show), illustrating the depth of Vault-Tec's ethical lapses:
- Vault 13: While not as overt with its experiments in the first game, Vault 13 was meant to test the Vault Dweller's ability to survive outside the vault after 200 years. The experiment here was more about isolation and dependency on Vault-Tec. However, the true horror comes from the realization that the vault would never have opened if not for the Vault Dweller's actions, essentially trapping residents indefinitely.
Ethical Horror: The manipulation of human life and destiny, turning survival into an unwitting experiment.
- Vault 15: This vault was a social experiment where different socio-economic and cultural groups were placed together, intended to foster conflict and observe how they would merge or clash. The vault was designed to fail, leading to its early opening and the scattering of its residents, which led to the founding of several settlements, including Arroyo.
Ethical Horror: Orchestrating societal conflict and division for observation, essentially using human lives as variables in a social experiment.
- Vault 112: Residents were trapped in a virtual reality simulation controlled by Dr. Stanislaus Braun, where they could live out idealized lives or suffer in nightmares, all at the whim of Braun.
Ethical Horror: The complete control over someone's consciousness, the denial of any real life or death, and the potential for eternal suffering or manipulation show a profound lack of ethical consideration. It delves into themes of psychological torture and the ethics of virtual reality.
- Vault 11: Vault 11 required its residents to sacrifice one of their own each year to keep the vault running. The twist was that this was unnecessary; the vault would function without any sacrifices. The true experiment was to see how long the community would continue this practice before rebelling or collapsing under its own moral weight.
Ethical Horror: Pushing people into making horrific choices, testing the limits of morality and humanity under extreme pressure.
- Vault 88: Vault 88 was supposed to be a testbed for Vault-Tec's social experiments, but the specifics were left to the player to decide via the "Vault-Tec Workshop" DLC. However, the inherent design was for continuous, customizable experiments on unknowing subjects.
Ethical Horror: The idea of a never-ending cycle of human experimentation where the vault itself is a tool for ongoing, potentially cruel experiments, with the player becoming complicit in Vault-Tec's legacy.
- Vault 51: This vault was unique in that it lacked a human overseer, instead being managed by a ZAX supercomputer. The experiment was to determine the best method for selecting a leader by putting dwellers through survival scenarios and leadership challenges. However, the ZAX unit, designed to escalate these scenarios, resulted in violence, murder, and chaos, with no clear end to the cycle of leadership tests.
Ethical Horror: The experiment essentially gamified human survival and leadership, using people as pieces in a deadly game without regard for their well-being, showcasing how technology can dehumanize and control human lives.
- Vault 32: While not detailed in full in the games, the TV show introduces Vault 32 as part of a tripartite experiment with Vaults 31 and 33. Vault 32 was designed to intermarry with Vault 33 to create a new, loyal Vault-Tec workforce. However, it's revealed that Vault 32's residents learned of their manipulation, leading to a breakdown where they killed each other, turned to cannibalism, or committed suicide.
Ethical Horror: The manipulation of human life for corporate loyalty, including breeding programs and the psychological horror of realizing one's entire existence was part of a corporate strategy, leading to social collapse and self-destruction.
Survival Necessity or Ethical Overreach?
Vault-Tec's experiments in the Fallout series are a narrative vehicle to explore profound ethical questions. They force us to consider how we balance the imperative of survival with the ethics of governance, science, and human rights. As we reflect on these virtual scenarios, we're compelled to ask: In a world where survival is no longer guaranteed, can we afford to maintain our ethical standards, or do we risk becoming the very monsters we fear in the dark?
The vault experiments thus serve not only as a plot device but as a profound narrative choice that reflects on human nature, governance, and the ethical boundaries of science, all within the unique, satirical, and often dark humor of the Fallout universe.
If this exploration of ethics through the Fallout lens intrigues you, perhaps consider how these themes are reflected in our own world. Are there parallels in our current scientific endeavors, governmental policies, or societal structures? And more importantly, how do we ensure that in our quest for survival, we don't lose what makes us human?
Let's keep the conversation going! Share your thoughts on the ethics of Vault-Tec's experiments or explore more of the Fallout universe with us in our Discord Server. Comment below, and don't forget to subscribe for more deep dives into the moral quandaries of the wasteland.
If you're reading this post in FH Companion app, this article will get you to the web version where you can leave the comment. For all other articles check the Fallout Hub Blog.
What are your thoughts on the Vault experiments? And which one do you think is the "most intriguing" or "morally complex", let me know!
ReplyDelete